you're reading...

ISMGA alleges attempts to debase Ayush courses by VC of Dr MGR Medical University

Chennai (PB): The Indian Siddha Medical Graduates Association (ISMGA), in a letter to the Union Minister of Health and Family Welfare, Gulam Nabi Azad, alleged that the Vice-Chancellor of The Tamil Nadu Dr MGR Medical University, Dr Mayil Vahanan Natarajan is persistently making attempts to debase the Indian Systems of Medicine (ISM). And the best evidence of it is in his latest letter to the Union Minister asking permission to remove the term ‘surgery’ from the nomenclature of undergraduate level ISM courses.

The association requested the minister to discard the proposal of the VC for changing the nomenclatures as the vice chancellor is deliberately trying to lower the dignity of the courses.

In a complaint to the Union minister, Dr Selvin Innocent Das, president of ISMGA said the vice-chancellor’s move will create a bad picture before the public and also before the international stake holders about the country’s traditional healing methods. He informed the minister that this is the second time Dr Mayil Vahanan Natarajan is making efforts to degrade the dignity of ISM courses. The reason he pointed out in the letter is that the VC is an allopath, so he is trying to lower the dignity of the Ayush systems.

Another allegation in the complaint is that the vice chancellor had failed in his earlier such attempt in this regard because of the intervention of the chief minister. Now, for a second time he is trying to use the good offices of the union minister to get his things done. Dr Selvin wrote in his letter that in the past, without getting the approval of the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM), which is the apex statutory body to introduce, monitor, alter or modify the ISM courses, the VC tried to take away some major portions from the syllabus of the ISM courses including surgery.

According to him the need of the hour is to update the existing syllabus with the latest advances in the medical sciences, which have been in use for decades. He said because of protests from Ayush students and practitioners the VC had earlier promised to the government of Tamil Nadu that there would not be any action from his side either to degrade or belittle the Indian systems. Now he is acting against his commitment, Dr Selvin wrote in the letter.

“All the actions taken by the VC in this regard are against the Indian Medicine Central Council Act 1970, and against the constitution. There are more than 1000 medical colleges on Ayush throughout India adhering CCIM Acts and regulations,” Dr Selvin said.

On March 26, this year the VC sent a letter to the health minister stating that the Medical University is embarked on revamping the curriculum and syllabus of Medical/Dental/ISM/Allied health sciences like pharmacy, nursing, physiotherapy etc commensurate with the recent advances in respective fields, and bring them from knowledge based to competence based systems.

Commenting that the term ‘surgery’ suffixed to BAMS, BUMS, BHMS and BSMS can give wrong notion to the public that these graduates are capable of performing surgeries, the VC wrote in his letter that the term ‘surgery’ could be used only when the candidate was exposed to the training for performing surgeries on the patients.

Dr Mayil Vahanan Natarajan made the suggestion before the minister that the term ‘surgery’ suffixed to each undergraduate ISM course be removed and the nomenclature of the courses be redesigned accordingly.

The Vice Chancellor of the Medical University is an orthopaedic surgeon with PhD in orthopaedic oncology.



One thought on “ISMGA alleges attempts to debase Ayush courses by VC of Dr MGR Medical University

  1. in addition to support the S letter of graduate degrees in AYUSH i have to say that the nomenclature, syllabus of education and its degree are being regulated by the apex body CCIM under Act 1970 and the degrees depicts the crystal clearance about the respective field of systems of medicine.

    However MBBS ( MBBS (bachelors of medicine and bachelors of surgery) does not reflect the nomenclature of system i.e allopathy. Moreover it is used in differnt ways in other part of world, The Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery degrees are having different pattern (MB BS or MB ChB, and several variants).

    For example
    1. in Romania The degree awarded is Doctor-medic (Medical Doctor) abbreviated as MD.
    2. In Germany students having completed 6 years of medical school and two rigorous state examinations acquire the right to work as a physician but no definite title.
    3. In Mexico, schools of medicine award the “Titulo de Medico Cirujano” degree after completing either 6 or 7 years of study.
    4. In mainland China, some medical schools award MBBS to foreign students while all medical schools award Bachelor of Medicine to nationals.
    5. In Indonesia, the title of “dokter” (dr.) is awarded after a Medical student received their Bachelor in Medicine (Sarjana Kedokteran; S.Ked) after 3-3,5 years of study (at least) and 1,5 – 2 years of clinical course in university hospitals. After a medical student finished those 5 years of study and take Hippocrates Oath,

    Moreover, without mentioning of system of medicine in degree, the letter S represents surgery in MBBS. It is also a fact that and the master of allopathic surgery -Hamilton Bailey mentioned that the Sushrut is the father of surgery. And every body has to know that Sushrut belongs to ISM system.
    Hence forth rather than wasting of energy of high knowledge in pulling down the basics of any system all pathies should think about the otimal health care of humanity in the form of total health.

    Posted by Dr. Raakhi Mehra | May 5, 2012, 12:34 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: